Best Bets


Written and Composed by James Donahower and Jake Smith;
Directed by Jeff Walsh
Part of the 2018 New York International Fringe Festival

Off Off Broadway, Musical
Runs through 10.22.18
FringeHUB, 685 Washington Street


by Jake Goldbas on 10.15.18


EnlargementJames Donahower and Jake Smith in Enlargement. Photo by James Donahower.


BOTTOM LINE: Enlargement is a joyfully juvenile, but also smart, musical comedy, with terrific songs and a light-hearted spirit.

The new musical Enlargement tells the story of Benny (Jake Smith), who wants confidence to be more popular in high school. Benny goes online and mistakenly clicks on spam, but in perhaps the play’s most fantastical element, the spam works, and sells penis-enlargement pills that are actually effective. This tarzanium supplement is the creation of mad scientist Professor von Plume (James Donahower). Benny’s newfound extension gives him confidence to talk to girls, sing at a pep rally, and stand up to bullies that he didn’t have before. When his friends at school, including Mike (Ken McGraw), find out he’s taking the pills, trouble and hijinks ensue.

Enlargement takes musical theatre show tunes and adds dick jokes, innuendo, and double entendres, so the musical is both familiar and original, reminiscent of South Park and The Book of Mormon. Audiences will love how Enlargement’s excellent songs vamp solos and choruses over prolonged outros—each actor knows how to hit their last notes and hit them hiiiiiiighhhhhh! As for the dick jokes, Enlargement has LOTS of them. And these jokes hit—they run fast, whether puns, songs, or both. The key ingredient might be the critical distance granted by the fact that this musical borders on the extremely wacky. Whatever it is, the ensemble sells the writing well.

But Enlargement isn't all dick jokes. At one point, Russian pharmacy spammer Evka (Cynthia Bonacum) breaks out her ukulele to sing about Judy Garland. Garland, who in real life died from a barbiturate overdose, is portrayed here optimistically, as a world traveler in The Wizard of Oz, and Evka's song is about the courage to be oneself. To the extent this is about the limits of a musical to persuade its viewers to take this courageous perspective, this song is a patient and loving lament. The answers might be in a pill, or in love, and maybe somewhere else, too.

While there is a big and surprising climax (sorry) to this musical, the final song is somewhat quieter, and talks about love. In fact, the ending is oddly mature for such a willfully juvenile play. The more self-conscious Benny gains a new perspective, and learns that the positive consequences might not be what he had expected. Enlargement is a smart, funny musical, and highly recommended.

(Enlargement plays at FringeHUB, 685 Washington Street at Charles Street, through October 22, 2018. Meet at the DARK GREEN FringeNYC flag. The running time is 2 hours 10 minutes, with one intermission. Performances are Sat 10/13 at 4, Sun 10/14 at 4:30, Wed 10/17 at 9:15, Sun 10/21 at 9:30, and Mon 10/22 at 9:30. There is no late seating at FringeNYC. Tickets are $22 (plus $3.69 ticketing fee), $16 (plus $3.51) for seniors, and are ONLY available online at For more information visit


Enlargement is written and composed by James Donahower and Jake Smith. Directed by Jeff Walsh. Music Direction by Ricky Romano. Lighting Design by Nick Probst. Sound Engineering by Ian Wehrle. Choreography by Lexi Orphanos. Artwork by Matt Czap. Stage Manager is Nick Probst.

The cast is Jake Smith, James Donahower, Ken McGraw, McLean Peterson, and Cynthia Bonacum.