Best Bets


By Leah Sarbib; Directed by Tosca Giustini
Produced by Bref
Part of the 2016 New York International Fringe Festival

Off Off Broadway, Play
Runs through 8.26.16
VENUE #11: 64E4 MAINSTAGE, 64 East 4th Street


by Danielle Feder on 8.18.16


RoadkillWill Lupica, Lorena Niera, Kathleen Gudas, and Kean Haunt (Middlebury College cast) in Roadkill. Photo by Michael O'Hara.


BOTTOM LINE: Roadkill is an energetic and intelligent look at sexuality, feminism, and the ways we relate to one another.

Lindsey McPherson is a slut, or so we’re told; the truth is a bit more complicated. In this devised work, created as playwright Leah Sarbib and director Tosca Giustini’s college thesis, four friends embark on a long car trip, and conversation quickly turns to their friend Lindsey (Leah Sarbib), who mysteriously dropped out of school and went off the grid. As each one defends their individual memory of Lindsey, shifting in and out of flashbacks and imagination, we begin to gain a fuller picture.

Three of them have known Lindsey for a long time: Taylor (Chelsea Melone) and Lindsey were best friends (and almost—maybe—more?); Taylor’s boyfriend Cameron (Will Lupica) went to summer camp with Lindsey when they were kids; and Jordan (Jabari Matthew) grew up with Lindsey and is still in love with her. The fourth, Santana (Tosca Giustini), is new to their school and, to her knowledge, has never met Lindsey. As the conversation shifts to evoke feelings of betrayal, loss, confusion, and love, we learn a great deal about Lindsey through seeing snippets of her interactions with these friends.

We watch Lindsey openly discuss sexual fluidity, explain around a campfire—in great detail —the type of porn she watches and how she masturbates, show up at a Tulsa college campus and easily make a friend, and confidently use sex as the only social currency she was taught she possessed. We’re told in the opening line of the play, and even in the show description, that Lindsey McPherson is a slut, and then we watch the term get dismantled before our eyes.

The most impressive part of this piece is how entirely organic it feels. What could be lengthy, academic discussions of feminist theory are successfully conveyed in short, insightful observations about how women operate in our society, arising naturally from their conversation, like Taylor’s statement that saying sorry “is like the ‘um’ of my life.” The show slips in and out of reality, briefly turning into fake car radio commercials or musical interludes that further explain a character’s feelings about Lindsey. In a show so much about sex, the actors do exactly what you’d expect to a bunch of bananas; this goofiness also helps to balance the moments that might otherwise feel too dry.

Roadkill succeeds at questioning one of the most pervasive issues women deal with, all without uttering the word “feminist.” Needless to say, you don’t need to have a degree in Gender Studies to get something out of this entertaining hour.

(Roadkill plays at VENUE #11: 64E4 MAINSTAGE, 64 East 4th Street, through August 26, 2016. The running time is 1 hour 10 minutes. Performances are Sun 8/14 at 6:30; Thu 8/18 at 9:30; Sun 8/21 at 4:15; Mon 8/22 at 7:15; and Fri 8/26 at 4. There is no late seating at FringeNYC. Tickets are $18 and are available at For more information visit


Roadkill is by Leah Sarbib. Directed by Tosca Giustini. Costume Design is by Iram Asghar. Set Design is by Lucy Killian. Lighting Design is by Björn Anders Peterson. Sound Design is by Ben Rose.

The cast is Tosca Giustini, Will Lupica, Jabari Matthew, Chelsea Melone, and Leah Sarbib.